This is my second year going into Easter after studying Islam. It wasn't so bad this second time around. I realized right away I couldn't really participate. Its not like at Christmas. They are mostly songs and prayers of "YAY Jesus is here!" which Unitarian and Muslim wise is totally fine. Christmas is easy. Its just Jesus' birthday. But Easter is rough. I basically just sat or stood and took it all in. I observed. And it was the first time in a long time I enjoyed church. I wasn't trying to make myself believe anything anymore. I took it in for what it is: a beautiful expression of faith. Church is really a beautiful thing. If you've never been I highly recommend sitting in on a service. Its quite lovely. But I know I don't belong there. And I'm not going to ever be able to go back to trinitarian christianity. Even with my belief in the crucifixion, Easter mass was too difficult. So much praying to Jesus!
The priest actually talked about the people who believe the crucifixion didn't happen. His reasoning for why this has to be false was rather amusing. His reasoning was that St. Peter, St. Paul (not the apostle) and the rest of his followers were uneducated, simple, men who were mostly fishermen. They did not have the capacity to make up such an elaborate story! Which made me want to go: So Muhammad (as) simple, unlearned man who worked in the trade business. Not a writer, or an overly educated being. Just a regular man. And he alone brought the entire Qur'an. So shouldn't that mean, Mr. Priest, that the Qur'an is also true? Hmmmm? :)
I have gotten to the point where I consider myself Unitarian Christian. But I am not nearly ready to come out as a muslim. Its still hard for me to accept the immense responsibilities. So many things that weren't sins instantly become sins (Not being clothed head to toe, eating non halal foods, praying on your period, missing prayers, interaction with the opposite sex etc). So much added responsibility. Plus I realized how hard it could be with family who will never understand.
One step at a time.